Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (102-105)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:102-105
Refs {'start': {'reference': '102', 'human_reference': 'Section 102'}, 'end': {'reference': '105', 'human_reference': 'Section 105'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why do they name boys when they are nine days old, but girls when they are eight days old?

Does the precedence of the girls have Nature as its cause? It is a fact that the female grows up, and attains maturity and perfection before the male. As for the days, they take those that follow the seventh: for the seventh is dangerous for newly-born children in various ways and in the matter of the umbilical cord: for in most cases this comes away on the seventh day: but until it comes off, the child is more like a plant than an animal.[*]

Or did they, like the adherents of Pythagoras, regard the even number as female and the odd number as male?[*] For the odd number is generative, and, when it is added to the even number, it prevails over it. And also, when they are divided into units, the even number, like the female, yields a vacant space between, while of the odd number an integral part always remains. Wherefore they think that the odd is suitable for the male, and the even for the female.

Or is it that of all numbers nine[*] is the first square from the odd and perfect triad, while eight is the first cube from the even dyad? Now a man should be four-square,[*] eminent, and perfect; but a woman, like a cube, should be stable, domestic, and difficult to remove from her place. And this should be added,

that eight is the cube of two arid nine the square of three: women have two names, men have three.

Why do they call children of unknown fathers spurii?[*]

Now the reason is not, as the Greeks believe and lawyers in court are wont to assert, that these children are begotten of some promiscuous and common seed: but Spurius is a first name like Sextus and Decimus and Gaius. They do not write first names in full, but by one letter, as Titus (T.) and Lucius (L.) and Marcus (M.): or by two, as Tiberius (Ti.) and Gnaeus (Cn.): or by three, as Sextus (Sex.) and Servius (Ser.). Spurius, then, is one of those written by two letters: Sp. And by these two letters they also denote children of unknown fathers, sine patre,[*] that is without a father: by the s they indicate sine and by the p patre. This, then, caused the error, the writing of the same abbreviation for sine patre and for Spurius.

I must state the other explanation also, but it is somewhat absurd: They assert that the Sabines use the word spurius for the pudenda muliebria, and it later came about that they called the child born of an unmarried, unespoused woman by this name, as if in mockery.

Why do they call Bacchus Liber Pater (Free Father)?[*]

Is it because he is the father of freedom to drinkers? For most people become bold and are abounding in frank speech when they are in their cups.[*] Or is it because he has provided the means for libations?

Or is it derived, as Alexander[*] asserts, from Dionysus Eleuthereus,[*] so named from Eleutherae in Boeotia?

For what reason is it not the custom for maidens to marry on public holidays, but widows do marry at this time?[*]

Is it, as Varro has remarked, that maidens are grieved over marrying, but older women are glad, and on a holiday one should do nothing in grief or by constraint?

Or is it rather because it is seemly that not a few should be present when maidens marry, but disgraceful that many should be present when widows marry? Now the first marriage is enviable: but the second is to be deprecated, for women are ashamed if they take a second husband while the first husband is still living, and they feel sad if they do so when he is dead. Wherefore they rejoice in a quiet wedding rather than in noise and processions. Holidays distract most people, so that they have no leisure for such matters.

Or, because they seized the maiden daughters of the Sabines at a holiday festival, and thereby became involved in war, did they come to regard it as ill-omened to marry maidens on holy days?

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
do 1 w 5
they 1 w 9
name 1 w 13
boys 1 w 17
when 1 w 21
they 2 w 25
are 1 w 28
nine 1 w 32
days 1 w 36
old 1 w 39
but 1 w 43
girls 1 w 48
when 2 w 52
they 3 w 56
are 2 w 59
eight 1 w 64
days 2 w 68
old 2 w 71
Does 1 w 76
the 4 w 79
precedence 1 w 89
of 1 w 91
the 5 w 94
girls 2 w 99
have 1 w 103
Nature 1 w 109
as 1 w 111
its 1 w 114
cause 1 w 119
It 1 w 122
is 1 w 124
a 10 w 125
fact 1 w 129
that 1 w 133
the 6 w 136
female 1 w 142
grows 1 w 147
up 1 w 149
and 1 w 153
attains 1 w 160
maturity 1 w 168
and 2 w 171
perfection 1 w 181
before 1 w 187
the 7 w 190
male 2 w 194
As 1 w 197
for 2 w 200
the 8 w 203
days 3 w 207
they 4 w 212
take 1 w 216
those 1 w 221
that 2 w 225
follow 1 w 231
the 10 w 234
seventh 1 w 241
for 3 w 245
the 11 w 248
seventh 2 w 255
is 2 w 257
dangerous 1 w 266
for 4 w 269
newly-born 1 w 279
children 1 w 287
in 3 w 289
various 1 w 296
ways 1 w 300
and 3 w 303
in 4 w 305
the 12 w 308
matter 1 w 314
of 2 w 316
the 13 w 319
umbilical 1 w 328
cord 1 w 332
for 5 w 336
in 5 w 338
most 1 w 342
cases 1 w 347
this 1 w 351
comes 1 w 356
away 1 w 360
on 2 w 362
the 14 w 365
seventh 3 w 372
day 4 w 375
but 2 w 379
until 1 w 384
it 3 w 386
comes 2 w 391
off 1 w 394
the 15 w 398
child 2 w 403
is 4 w 405
more 1 w 409
like 1 w 413
a 33 w 414
plant 1 w 419
than 1 w 423
an 7 w 425
animal 1 w 431
Cf 1 w 434
Aulus 1 w 440
Gellius 1 w 447
xvi 1 w 451
16 1 w 454
2-3 1 w 458
Or 1 w 461
did 1 w 464
they 5 w 468
like 2 w 473
the 17 w 476
adherents 1 w 485
of 4 w 487
Pythagoras 1 w 497
regard 1 w 504
the 18 w 507
even 4 w 511
number 1 w 517
as 4 w 519
female 2 w 525
and 4 w 528
the 19 w 531
odd 1 w 534
number 2 w 540
as 5 w 542
male 4 w 546
Cf 2 w 549
264 1 w 553
a 48 w 554
supra 1 w 560
For 1 w 564
the 20 w 567
odd 2 w 570
number 3 w 576
is 5 w 578
generative 1 w 588
and 5 w 592
when 3 w 597
it 4 w 599
is 6 w 601
added 1 w 606
to 1 w 608
the 21 w 611
even 5 w 615
number 4 w 621
it 5 w 624
prevails 1 w 632
over 1 w 636
it 6 w 638
And 1 w 642
also 1 w 646
when 4 w 651
they 6 w 655
are 3 w 658
divided 1 w 665
into 1 w 669
units 1 w 674
the 23 w 678
even 6 w 682
number 5 w 688
like 3 w 693
the 24 w 696
female 3 w 702
yields 1 w 709
a 57 w 710
vacant 1 w 716
space 1 w 721
between 1 w 728
while 1 w 734
of 5 w 736
the 25 w 739
odd 3 w 742
number 6 w 748
an 12 w 750
integral 1 w 758
part 1 w 762
always 1 w 768
remains 1 w 775
Wherefore 1 w 785
they 7 w 789
think 1 w 794
that 3 w 798
the 27 w 801
odd 4 w 804
is 7 w 806
suitable 1 w 814
for 7 w 817
the 28 w 820
male 6 w 824
and 6 w 828
the 29 w 831
even 7 w 835
for 8 w 838
the 30 w 841
female 4 w 847
Or 2 w 850
is 8 w 852
it 9 w 854
that 4 w 858
of 6 w 860
all 1 w 863
numbers 1 w 870
nine 2 w 874
Cf 3 w 876
Moralia 1 w 884
744 1 w 888
a-b 1 w 891
is 9 w 894
the 31 w 897
first 1 w 902
square 1 w 908
from 1 w 912
the 32 w 915
odd 5 w 918
and 7 w 921
perfect 2 w 928
triad 1 w 933
while 2 w 939
eight 2 w 944
is 10 w 946
the 33 w 949
first 2 w 954
cube 1 w 958
from 2 w 962
the 34 w 965
even 8 w 969
dyad 1 w 973
Now 1 w 977
a 81 w 978
man 1 w 981
should 1 w 987
be 11 w 989
four-square 1 w 1000
Cf 4 w 1003
Bergk 1 w 1009
Poet 1 w 1014
Lyr 1 w 1018
Graec 1 w 1024
Simonides 1 w 1035
Frag 1 w 1040
5 1 w 1042
or 15 w 1045
Edmonds 1 w 1052
Lyra 1 w 1057
Graeca 1 w 1063
in 11 w 1066
L 3 w 1067
C 5 w 1069
L 4 w 1071
ii 1 w 1074
p 10 w 1076
284 1 w 1080
eminent 1 w 1089
and 8 w 1093
perfect 3 w 1100
but 3 w 1104
a 90 w 1105
woman 1 w 1110
like 4 w 1115
a 92 w 1116
cube 2 w 1120
should 2 w 1127
be 13 w 1129
stable 1 w 1135
domestic 1 w 1144
and 9 w 1148
difficult 1 w 1157
to 3 w 1159
remove 1 w 1165
from 3 w 1169
her 3 w 1172
place 1 w 1177
And 2 w 1181
this 2 w 1185
should 3 w 1191
be 14 w 1193
added 2 w 1198
that 5 w 1203
eight 3 w 1208
is 12 w 1210
the 35 w 1213
cube 3 w 1217
of 7 w 1219
two 1 w 1222
arid 1 w 1226
nine 3 w 1230
the 36 w 1233
square 3 w 1239
of 8 w 1241
three 1 w 1246
women 1 w 1252
have 2 w 1256
two 2 w 1259
names 1 w 1264
men 2 w 1268
have 3 w 1272
three 2 w 1277
Why 2 w 1281
do 3 w 1283
they 8 w 1287
call 1 w 1291
children 2 w 1299
of 9 w 1301
unknown 1 w 1308
fathers 1 w 1315
spurii 1 w 1321
Cf 5 w 1324
Gaius 1 w 1330
Institutiones 1 w 1344
i 80 w 1346
64 2 w 1349
Valerius 1 w 1358
Maximus 1 w 1365
De 1 w 1368
Praenominibus 1 w 1381
6 4 w 1383
p 14 w 1385
590 1 w 1389
of 10 w 1391
Kempf 1 w 1396
s 75 w 1398
ed 5 w 1400
Now 2 w 1406
the 39 w 1409
reason 1 w 1415
is 13 w 1417
not 1 w 1420
as 7 w 1423
the 40 w 1426
Greeks 1 w 1432
believe 1 w 1439
and 10 w 1442
lawyers 1 w 1449
in 15 w 1451
court 1 w 1456
are 7 w 1459
wont 1 w 1463
to 4 w 1465
assert 1 w 1471
that 6 w 1476
these 1 w 1481
children 3 w 1489
are 8 w 1492
begotten 1 w 1500
of 11 w 1502
some 1 w 1506
promiscuous 1 w 1517
and 11 w 1520
common 1 w 1526
seed 1 w 1530
but 4 w 1534
Spurius 1 w 1541
is 15 w 1543
a 118 w 1544
first 3 w 1549
name 3 w 1553
like 5 w 1557
Sextus 1 w 1563
and 12 w 1566
Decimus 1 w 1573
and 13 w 1576
Gaius 2 w 1581
They 1 w 1586
do 4 w 1588
not 2 w 1591
write 1 w 1596
first 4 w 1601
names 2 w 1606
in 16 w 1608
full 1 w 1612
but 5 w 1616
by 1 w 1618
one 2 w 1621
letter 1 w 1627
as 9 w 1630
Titus 1 w 1635
T 3 w 1637
and 14 w 1642
Lucius 1 w 1648
L 6 w 1650
and 15 w 1655
Marcus 1 w 1661
M 4 w 1663
or 16 w 1668
by 2 w 1670
two 3 w 1673
as 10 w 1676
Tiberius 1 w 1684
Ti 3 w 1687
and 16 w 1692
Gnaeus 1 w 1698
Cn 1 w 1701
or 17 w 1706
by 3 w 1708
three 3 w 1713
as 11 w 1716
Sextus 2 w 1722
Sex 3 w 1726
and 17 w 1731
Servius 1 w 1738
Ser 2 w 1742
Spurius 2 w 1752
then 1 w 1757
is 16 w 1760
one 3 w 1763
of 12 w 1765
those 2 w 1770
written 1 w 1777
by 4 w 1779
two 4 w 1782
letters 1 w 1789
Sp 3 w 1792
And 3 w 1796
by 5 w 1798
these 2 w 1803
two 5 w 1806
letters 2 w 1813
they 9 w 1817
also 2 w 1821
denote 1 w 1827
children 4 w 1835
of 13 w 1837
unknown 2 w 1844
fathers 2 w 1851
sine 1 w 1856
patre 1 w 1861
The 2 w 1865
mss 1 w 1868
have 4 w 1873
sine 2 w 1877
patris 1 w 1883
did 2 w 1887
Plutarch 1 w 1895
or 18 w 1898
some 2 w 1902
Greek 2 w 1907
copyist 1 w 1914
confuse 1 w 1922
the 46 w 1925
Latin 1 w 1930
genitive 1 w 1938
and 18 w 1941
ablative 1 w 1949
since 1 w 1955
they 10 w 1959
are 9 w 1962
one 4 w 1965
in 21 w 1967
Greek 3 w 1972
that 7 w 1977
is 19 w 1979
without 1 w 1986
a 145 w 1987
father 3 w 1993
by 6 w 1996
the 49 w 1999
s 124 w 2000
they 11 w 2004
indicate 1 w 2012
sine 3 w 2016
and 19 w 2019
by 7 w 2021
the 51 w 2024
p 23 w 2025
patre 2 w 2030
This 1 w 2035
then 2 w 2040
caused 1 w 2047
the 53 w 2050
error 1 w 2055
the 54 w 2059
writing 1 w 2066
of 14 w 2068
the 55 w 2071
same 1 w 2075
abbreviation 1 w 2087
for 9 w 2090
sine 4 w 2094
patre 3 w 2099
and 20 w 2102
for 10 w 2105
Spurius 3 w 2112
I 3 w 2114
must 1 w 2118
state 1 w 2123
the 56 w 2126
other 1 w 2131
explanation 1 w 2142
also 3 w 2146
but 6 w 2150
it 17 w 2152
is 21 w 2154
somewhat 1 w 2162
absurd 1 w 2168
They 2 w 2173
assert 2 w 2179
that 8 w 2183
the 58 w 2186
Sabines 1 w 2193
use 4 w 2196
the 59 w 2199
word 1 w 2203
spurius 1 w 2210
for 11 w 2213
the 60 w 2216
pudenda 1 w 2223
muliebria 1 w 2232
and 21 w 2236
it 18 w 2238
later 1 w 2243
came 1 w 2247
about 1 w 2252
that 9 w 2256
they 12 w 2260
called 1 w 2266
the 62 w 2269
child 6 w 2274
born 2 w 2278
of 15 w 2280
an 32 w 2282
unmarried 1 w 2291
unespoused 1 w 2302
woman 2 w 2307
by 8 w 2309
this 3 w 2313
name 5 w 2317
as 13 w 2320
if 2 w 2322
in 27 w 2324
mockery 1 w 2331
Why 3 w 2335
do 5 w 2337
they 13 w 2341
call 3 w 2345
Bacchus 1 w 2352
Liber 1 w 2357
Pater 1 w 2362
Free 1 w 2367
Father 1 w 2373
Cf 6 w 2377
Petronius 1 w 2387
Satyricon 1 w 2397
41 1 w 2400
and 22 w 2404
Housman 1 w 2411
s 150 w 2413
commentary 1 w 2423
in 28 w 2425
Classical 1 w 2434
Review 1 w 2440
xxxii 1 w 2446
p 31 w 2448
164 1 w 2452
Is 1 w 2455
it 19 w 2457
because 1 w 2464
he 75 w 2466
is 23 w 2468
the 65 w 2471
father 4 w 2477
of 16 w 2479
freedom 1 w 2486
to 5 w 2488
drinkers 1 w 2496
For 2 w 2500
most 2 w 2504
people 1 w 2510
become 1 w 2516
bold 1 w 2520
and 23 w 2523
are 10 w 2526
abounding 1 w 2535
in 31 w 2537
frank 1 w 2542
speech 1 w 2548
when 5 w 2552
they 14 w 2556
are 11 w 2559
in 32 w 2561
their 1 w 2566
cups 1 w 2570
Cf 7 w 2573
Moralia 2 w 2581
716 1 w 2585
b 53 w 2586
Or 3 w 2589
is 24 w 2591
it 20 w 2593
because 2 w 2600
he 81 w 2602
has 1 w 2605
provided 1 w 2613
the 69 w 2616
means 1 w 2621
for 12 w 2624
libations 1 w 2633
Or 4 w 2636
is 25 w 2638
it 21 w 2640
derived 1 w 2647
as 16 w 2650
Alexander 1 w 2659
Müller 1 w 2665
Frag 2 w 2670
Hist 1 w 2675
Graec 3 w 2681
iii 1 w 2685
p 37 w 2687
244 1 w 2691
Alexander 2 w 2701
Polyhistor 1 w 2711
asserts 1 w 2719
from 4 w 2724
Dionysus 1 w 2732
Eleuthereus 1 w 2743
Cf 8 w 2746
the 71 w 2750
inscription 1 w 2761
on 20 w 2763
the 72 w 2766
chair 1 w 2771
of 17 w 2773
the 73 w 2776
priest 1 w 2782
of 18 w 2784
Dionysus 2 w 2792
in 34 w 2794
the 74 w 2797
theatre 1 w 2804
at 36 w 2806
Athens 1 w 2812
Ἱερεῶς 1 w 2819
Διονύσου 1 w 2827
Ἐλευθερέως 1 w 2837
so 8 w 2840
named 1 w 2845
from 5 w 2849
Eleutherae 1 w 2859
in 35 w 2861
Boeotia 1 w 2868
For 3 w 2872
what 2 w 2876
reason 2 w 2882
is 28 w 2884
it 22 w 2886
not 4 w 2889
the 78 w 2892
custom 1 w 2898
for 13 w 2901
maidens 1 w 2908
to 8 w 2910
marry 1 w 2915
on 23 w 2917
public 1 w 2923
holidays 1 w 2931
but 7 w 2935
widows 1 w 2941
do 8 w 2943
marry 2 w 2948
at 38 w 2950
this 4 w 2954
time 1 w 2958
Cf 9 w 2961
Macrobius 1 w 2971
Saturnalia 1 w 2982
i 194 w 2984
15 1 w 2987
21 1 w 2990
Is 2 w 2993
it 23 w 2995
as 19 w 2998
Varro 1 w 3003
has 2 w 3006
remarked 1 w 3014
that 10 w 3019
maidens 2 w 3026
are 12 w 3029
grieved 1 w 3036
over 2 w 3040
marrying 1 w 3048
but 8 w 3052
older 1 w 3057
women 2 w 3062
are 13 w 3065
glad 1 w 3069
and 26 w 3073
on 24 w 3075
a 235 w 3076
holiday 2 w 3083
one 5 w 3086
should 4 w 3092
do 9 w 3094
nothing 1 w 3101
in 38 w 3103
grief 1 w 3108
or 31 w 3110
by 9 w 3112
constraint 1 w 3122
Or 5 w 3125
is 30 w 3127
it 24 w 3129
rather 1 w 3135
because 3 w 3142
it 25 w 3144
is 31 w 3146
seemly 1 w 3152
that 11 w 3156
not 6 w 3159
a 241 w 3160
few 1 w 3163
should 5 w 3169
be 24 w 3171
present 1 w 3178
when 6 w 3182
maidens 3 w 3189
marry 4 w 3194
but 9 w 3198
disgraceful 1 w 3209
that 12 w 3213
many 1 w 3217
should 6 w 3223
be 25 w 3225
present 2 w 3232
when 7 w 3236
widows 2 w 3242
marry 5 w 3247
Now 3 w 3251
the 80 w 3254
first 5 w 3259
marriage 1 w 3267
is 33 w 3269
enviable 1 w 3277
but 10 w 3281
the 81 w 3284
second 1 w 3290
is 34 w 3292
to 9 w 3294
be 26 w 3296
deprecated 1 w 3306
for 14 w 3310
women 3 w 3315
are 14 w 3318
ashamed 1 w 3325
if 3 w 3327
they 15 w 3331
take 2 w 3335
a 256 w 3336
second 2 w 3342
husband 1 w 3349
while 3 w 3354
the 83 w 3357
first 6 w 3362
husband 2 w 3369
is 35 w 3371
still 1 w 3376
living 1 w 3382
and 29 w 3386
they 16 w 3390
feel 1 w 3394
sad 1 w 3397
if 4 w 3399
they 17 w 3403
do 11 w 3405
so 10 w 3407
when 8 w 3411
he 102 w 3413
is 36 w 3415
dead 1 w 3419
Wherefore 2 w 3429
they 18 w 3433
rejoice 1 w 3440
in 41 w 3442
a 262 w 3443
quiet 1 w 3448
wedding 1 w 3455
rather 2 w 3461
than 2 w 3465
in 43 w 3467
noise 1 w 3472
and 30 w 3475
processions 1 w 3486
Holidays 1 w 3495
distract 1 w 3503
most 3 w 3507
people 2 w 3513
so 11 w 3516
that 13 w 3520
they 19 w 3524
have 5 w 3528
no 11 w 3530
leisure 1 w 3537
for 16 w 3540
such 1 w 3544
matters 1 w 3551
Or 6 w 3554
because 4 w 3562
they 20 w 3566
seized 1 w 3572
the 90 w 3575
maiden 4 w 3581
daughters 1 w 3590
of 19 w 3592
the 91 w 3595
Sabines 2 w 3602
at 48 w 3604
a 276 w 3605
holiday 3 w 3612
festival 1 w 3620
and 31 w 3624
thereby 1 w 3631
became 1 w 3637
involved 1 w 3645
in 46 w 3647
war 1 w 3650
did 3 w 3654
they 21 w 3658
come 4 w 3662
to 10 w 3664
regard 2 w 3670
it 26 w 3672
as 22 w 3674
ill-omened 1 w 3684
to 11 w 3686
marry 6 w 3691
maidens 4 w 3698
on 30 w 3700
holy 1 w 3704
days 6 w 3708