Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Lives of Eminent Philosophers

Lives of Eminent Philosophers (2.5.29-2.5.33)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:2.5.29-2.5.33
Refs {'start': {'reference': '2.5.29', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Chapter 5 Section 29'}, 'end': {'reference': '2.5.33', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Chapter 5 Section 33'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '2'}, {'reference': '2.5'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

He showed equal ability in both directions, in persuading and dissuading men; thus, after conversing with Theaetetus about knowledge, he sent him away, as Plato says, fired with a divine impulse; but when Euthyphro had indicted his father for manslaughter, Socrates, after some conversation with him upon piety, diverted him from his purpose. Lysis, again, he turned, by exhortation, into a most virtuous character. For he had the skill to draw his arguments from facts. And when his son

V1_161
Lamprocles was violently angry with his mother, Socrates made him feel ashamed of himself, as I believe Xenophon has told us. When Platos brother Glaucon was desirous of entering upon politics, Socrates dissuaded him, as Xenophon relates, because of his want of experience; but on the contrary he encouraged Charmides to take up politics because he had a gift that way.[*]

He roused Iphicrates the general to a martial spirit by showing him how the fighting cocks of Midias the barber flapped their wings in defiance of those of Callias. Glauconides demanded that he should be acquired for the state as if he were some pheasant or peacock.

He used to say it was strange that, if you asked a man how many sheep he had, he could easily tell you the precise number; whereas he could not name his friends or say how many he had, so slight was the value he set upon them. Seeing Euclides keenly interested in eristic arguments, he said to him: You will be able to get on with sophists, Euclides, but with men not at all. For he thought there was no use in this sort of hair-splitting, as Plato shows us in the Euthydemus.

Again, when Charmides offered him some slaves in order that he might derive an income from them, he declined the offer; and according to some he scorned the beauty of Alcibiades. He would extol leisure as the best of possessions, according to Xenophon in the Symposium. There is, he said, only one good, that is, knowledge, and only one evil, that is, ignorance; wealth and good birth bring their possessor no dignity, but on the contrary evil. At all events, when some one told him that Antisthenes mother

V1_163
was a Thracian, he replied, Nay, did you expect a man so noble to have been born of two Athenian parents? He made Crito ransom Phaedo who, having been taken prisoner in the war, was kept in degrading slavery, and so won him for philosophy.

Moreover, in his old age he learnt to play the lyre, declaring that he saw no absurdity in learning a new accomplishment. As Xenophon relates in the Symposium, it was his regular habit to dance, thinking that such exercise helped to keep the body in good condition. He used to say that his supernatural sign warned him beforehand of the future; that to make a good start was no trifling advantage, but a trifle turned the scale; and that he knew nothing except just the fact of his ignorance. He said that, when people paid a high price for fruit which had ripened early, they must despair of seeing the fruit ripen at the proper season. And, being once asked in what consisted the virtue of a young man, he said, In doing nothing to excess. He held that geometry should be studied to the point at which a man is able to measure the land which he acquires or parts with.

On hearing the line of Euripides play Auge where the poet says of virtue:

Tis best to let her roam at will,[*]
he got up and left the theatre. For he said it was absurd to make a hue and cry about a slave who could not be found, and to allow virtue to perish in this way. Some one asked him whether he should marry or not, and received the reply, Whichever you do you will repent it. He used to express his astonishment that the sculptors of marble statues
V1_165
should take pains to make the block of marble into a perfect likeness of a man, and should take no pains about themselves lest they should turn out mere blocks, not men. He recommended to the young the constant use of the mirror, to the end that handsome men might acquire a corresponding behaviour, and ugly men conceal their defects by education.

Tokens

He 1 w 2
showed 1 w 8
equal 1 w 13
ability 1 w 20
in 1 w 22
both 1 w 26
directions 1 w 36
in 2 w 39
persuading 1 w 49
and 1 w 52
dissuading 1 w 62
men 1 w 65
thus 1 w 70
after 1 w 76
conversing 1 w 86
with 1 w 90
Theaetetus 1 w 100
about 1 w 105
knowledge 1 w 114
he 2 w 117
sent 1 w 121
him 1 w 124
away 1 w 128
as 1 w 131
Plato 1 w 136
says 1 w 140
fired 1 w 146
with 2 w 150
a 14 w 151
divine 1 w 157
impulse 1 w 164
but 1 w 168
when 1 w 172
Euthyphro 1 w 181
had 1 w 184
indicted 1 w 192
his 1 w 195
father 1 w 201
for 1 w 204
manslaughter 1 w 216
Socrates 1 w 225
after 2 w 231
some 1 w 235
conversation 1 w 247
with 3 w 251
him 2 w 254
upon 1 w 258
piety 1 w 263
diverted 1 w 272
him 3 w 275
from 1 w 279
his 2 w 282
purpose 1 w 289
Lysis 1 w 295
again 1 w 301
he 5 w 304
turned 1 w 310
by 1 w 313
exhortation 1 w 324
into 1 w 329
a 25 w 330
most 1 w 334
virtuous 1 w 342
character 1 w 351
For 1 w 355
he 6 w 357
had 2 w 360
the 2 w 363
skill 1 w 368
to 3 w 370
draw 1 w 374
his 3 w 377
arguments 1 w 386
from 2 w 390
facts 1 w 395
And 1 w 399
when 2 w 403
his 4 w 406
son 1 w 409
Lamprocles 1 w 419
was 1 w 422
violently 1 w 431
angry 1 w 436
with 4 w 440
his 5 w 443
mother 1 w 449
Socrates 2 w 458
made 1 w 462
him 4 w 465
feel 1 w 469
ashamed 1 w 476
of 1 w 478
himself 1 w 485
as 4 w 488
I 1 w 489
believe 1 w 496
Xenophon 1 w 504
has 1 w 507
told 1 w 511
us 4 w 513
When 1 w 518
Plato 2 w 523
s 40 w 525
brother 1 w 532
Glaucon 1 w 539
was 2 w 542
desirous 1 w 550
of 2 w 552
entering 1 w 560
upon 2 w 564
politics 1 w 572
Socrates 3 w 581
dissuaded 1 w 590
him 6 w 593
as 7 w 596
Xenophon 2 w 604
relates 1 w 611
because 1 w 619
of 3 w 621
his 6 w 624
want 1 w 628
of 4 w 630
experience 1 w 640
but 2 w 644
on 12 w 646
the 5 w 649
contrary 1 w 657
he 13 w 659
encouraged 1 w 669
Charmides 1 w 678
to 6 w 680
take 1 w 684
up 3 w 686
politics 2 w 694
because 2 w 701
he 14 w 703
had 3 w 706
a 56 w 707
gift 1 w 711
that 1 w 715
way 2 w 718
Mem 1 w 722
iii 1 w 726
7 1 w 728
He 2 w 731
roused 1 w 737
Iphicrates 1 w 747
the 6 w 750
general 1 w 757
to 7 w 759
a 61 w 760
martial 1 w 767
spirit 1 w 773
by 2 w 775
showing 1 w 782
him 7 w 785
how 3 w 788
the 7 w 791
fighting 1 w 799
cocks 1 w 804
of 5 w 806
Midias 1 w 812
the 8 w 815
barber 1 w 821
flapped 1 w 828
their 1 w 833
wings 1 w 838
in 14 w 840
defiance 1 w 848
of 6 w 850
those 1 w 855
of 7 w 857
Callias 1 w 864
Glauconides 1 w 876
demanded 1 w 884
that 2 w 888
he 19 w 890
should 1 w 896
be 5 w 898
acquired 1 w 906
for 2 w 909
the 10 w 912
state 1 w 917
as 10 w 919
if 2 w 921
he 21 w 923
were 1 w 927
some 2 w 931
pheasant 1 w 939
or 5 w 941
peacock 1 w 948
He 3 w 951
used 2 w 955
to 8 w 957
say 2 w 960
it 9 w 962
was 3 w 965
strange 1 w 972
that 3 w 976
if 3 w 979
you 1 w 982
asked 1 w 987
a 84 w 988
man 3 w 991
how 4 w 994
many 1 w 998
sheep 1 w 1003
he 24 w 1005
had 4 w 1008
he 25 w 1011
could 1 w 1016
easily 1 w 1022
tell 1 w 1026
you 2 w 1029
the 11 w 1032
precise 1 w 1039
number 1 w 1045
whereas 1 w 1053
he 28 w 1055
could 2 w 1060
not 1 w 1063
name 1 w 1067
his 7 w 1070
friends 1 w 1077
or 6 w 1079
say 3 w 1082
how 5 w 1085
many 2 w 1089
he 29 w 1091
had 5 w 1094
so 4 w 1097
slight 1 w 1103
was 4 w 1106
the 12 w 1109
value 1 w 1114
he 31 w 1116
set 1 w 1119
upon 3 w 1123
them 1 w 1127
Seeing 1 w 1134
Euclides 1 w 1142
keenly 1 w 1148
interested 1 w 1158
in 17 w 1160
eristic 1 w 1167
arguments 2 w 1176
he 33 w 1179
said 1 w 1183
to 9 w 1185
him 8 w 1188
You 1 w 1192
will 1 w 1196
be 7 w 1198
able 1 w 1202
to 10 w 1204
get 1 w 1207
on 16 w 1209
with 5 w 1213
sophists 1 w 1221
Euclides 2 w 1230
but 3 w 1234
with 6 w 1238
men 4 w 1241
not 2 w 1244
at 15 w 1246
all 2 w 1249
For 2 w 1253
he 34 w 1255
thought 1 w 1262
there 1 w 1267
was 5 w 1270
no 6 w 1272
use 5 w 1275
in 18 w 1277
this 1 w 1281
sort 1 w 1285
of 8 w 1287
hair-splitting 1 w 1301
as 18 w 1304
Plato 3 w 1309
shows 1 w 1314
us 11 w 1316
in 20 w 1318
the 15 w 1321
Euthydemus 1 w 1331
Again 1 w 1337
when 3 w 1342
Charmides 2 w 1351
offered 1 w 1358
him 9 w 1361
some 3 w 1365
slaves 1 w 1371
in 22 w 1373
order 1 w 1378
that 4 w 1382
he 38 w 1384
might 1 w 1389
derive 1 w 1395
an 12 w 1397
income 1 w 1403
from 3 w 1407
them 2 w 1411
he 40 w 1414
declined 1 w 1422
the 17 w 1425
offer 2 w 1430
and 3 w 1434
according 1 w 1443
to 12 w 1445
some 4 w 1449
he 42 w 1451
scorned 1 w 1458
the 18 w 1461
beauty 1 w 1467
of 11 w 1469
Alcibiades 1 w 1479
He 4 w 1482
would 1 w 1487
extol 1 w 1492
leisure 1 w 1499
as 19 w 1501
the 19 w 1504
best 1 w 1508
of 12 w 1510
possessions 1 w 1521
according 2 w 1531
to 14 w 1533
Xenophon 3 w 1541
in 27 w 1543
the 20 w 1546
Symposium 1 w 1555
There 1 w 1561
is 16 w 1563
he 47 w 1566
said 2 w 1570
only 1 w 1575
one 1 w 1578
good 1 w 1582
that 5 w 1587
is 17 w 1589
knowledge 2 w 1599
and 4 w 1603
only 2 w 1607
one 2 w 1610
evil 1 w 1614
that 6 w 1619
is 18 w 1621
ignorance 1 w 1631
wealth 1 w 1638
and 5 w 1641
good 2 w 1645
birth 1 w 1650
bring 1 w 1655
their 2 w 1660
possessor 1 w 1669
no 10 w 1671
dignity 1 w 1678
but 4 w 1682
on 23 w 1684
the 22 w 1687
contrary 2 w 1695
evil 2 w 1699
At 1 w 1702
all 3 w 1705
events 1 w 1711
when 4 w 1716
some 5 w 1720
one 3 w 1723
told 2 w 1727
him 10 w 1730
that 7 w 1734
Antisthenes 1 w 1745
mother 2 w 1752
was 6 w 1755
a 127 w 1756
Thracian 1 w 1764
he 53 w 1767
replied 1 w 1774
Nay 1 w 1778
did 1 w 1782
you 3 w 1785
expect 1 w 1791
a 131 w 1792
man 6 w 1795
so 11 w 1797
noble 1 w 1802
to 16 w 1804
have 1 w 1808
been 1 w 1812
born 1 w 1816
of 13 w 1818
two 1 w 1821
Athenian 1 w 1829
parents 1 w 1836
He 5 w 1839
made 2 w 1843
Crito 1 w 1848
ransom 1 w 1854
Phaedo 1 w 1860
who 1 w 1863
having 1 w 1870
been 2 w 1874
taken 1 w 1879
prisoner 1 w 1887
in 30 w 1889
the 26 w 1892
war 1 w 1895
was 7 w 1899
kept 1 w 1903
in 31 w 1905
degrading 1 w 1914
slavery 1 w 1921
and 6 w 1925
so 14 w 1927
won 1 w 1930
him 11 w 1933
for 3 w 1936
philosophy 1 w 1946
Moreover 1 w 1955
in 33 w 1958
his 10 w 1961
old 3 w 1964
age 2 w 1967
he 56 w 1969
learnt 1 w 1975
to 18 w 1977
play 1 w 1981
the 27 w 1984
lyre 1 w 1988
declaring 1 w 1998
that 8 w 2002
he 58 w 2004
saw 1 w 2007
no 12 w 2009
absurdity 1 w 2018
in 35 w 2020
learning 1 w 2028
a 154 w 2029
new 1 w 2032
accomplishment 1 w 2046
As 1 w 2049
Xenophon 4 w 2057
relates 2 w 2064
in 37 w 2066
the 28 w 2069
Symposium 2 w 2078
it 16 w 2081
was 8 w 2084
his 11 w 2087
regular 1 w 2094
habit 1 w 2099
to 19 w 2101
dance 1 w 2106
thinking 1 w 2115
that 9 w 2119
such 1 w 2123
exercise 1 w 2131
helped 1 w 2137
to 20 w 2139
keep 1 w 2143
the 29 w 2146
body 1 w 2150
in 40 w 2152
good 3 w 2156
condition 1 w 2165
He 6 w 2168
used 3 w 2172
to 21 w 2174
say 4 w 2177
that 10 w 2181
his 12 w 2184
supernatural 1 w 2196
sign 1 w 2200
warned 1 w 2206
him 12 w 2209
beforehand 1 w 2219
of 14 w 2221
the 30 w 2224
future 1 w 2230
that 11 w 2235
to 22 w 2237
make 1 w 2241
a 170 w 2242
good 4 w 2246
start 1 w 2251
was 9 w 2254
no 14 w 2256
trifling 1 w 2264
advantage 1 w 2273
but 5 w 2277
a 176 w 2278
trifle 1 w 2284
turned 2 w 2290
the 31 w 2293
scale 1 w 2298
and 8 w 2302
that 12 w 2306
he 64 w 2308
knew 1 w 2312
nothing 1 w 2319
except 1 w 2325
just 1 w 2329
the 32 w 2332
fact 2 w 2336
of 15 w 2338
his 13 w 2341
ignorance 2 w 2350
He 7 w 2353
said 3 w 2357
that 13 w 2361
when 5 w 2366
people 1 w 2372
paid 1 w 2376
a 185 w 2377
high 1 w 2381
price 1 w 2386
for 5 w 2389
fruit 1 w 2394
which 1 w 2399
had 6 w 2402
ripened 1 w 2409
early 1 w 2414
they 1 w 2419
must 1 w 2423
despair 1 w 2430
of 16 w 2432
seeing 1 w 2438
the 34 w 2441
fruit 2 w 2446
ripen 2 w 2451
at 29 w 2453
the 35 w 2456
proper 1 w 2462
season 1 w 2468
And 2 w 2472
being 1 w 2478
once 1 w 2482
asked 2 w 2487
in 45 w 2489
what 1 w 2493
consisted 1 w 2502
the 36 w 2505
virtue 1 w 2511
of 17 w 2513
a 193 w 2514
young 1 w 2519
man 7 w 2522
he 71 w 2525
said 4 w 2529
In 1 w 2532
doing 1 w 2537
nothing 2 w 2544
to 23 w 2546
excess 1 w 2552
He 8 w 2555
held 1 w 2559
that 14 w 2563
geometry 1 w 2571
should 2 w 2577
be 14 w 2579
studied 1 w 2586
to 24 w 2588
the 37 w 2591
point 1 w 2596
at 32 w 2598
which 2 w 2603
a 198 w 2604
man 8 w 2607
is 28 w 2609
able 2 w 2613
to 25 w 2615
measure 1 w 2622
the 38 w 2625
land 1 w 2629
which 3 w 2634
he 75 w 2636
acquires 1 w 2644
or 21 w 2646
parts 1 w 2651
with 7 w 2655
On 1 w 2658
hearing 1 w 2665
the 39 w 2668
line 2 w 2672
of 18 w 2674
Euripides 1 w 2683
play 2 w 2688
Auge 1 w 2692
where 2 w 2697
the 40 w 2700
poet 1 w 2704
says 2 w 2708
of 19 w 2710
virtue 2 w 2716
Tis 1 w 2721
best 2 w 2725
to 26 w 2727
let 1 w 2730
her 9 w 2733
roam 1 w 2737
at 33 w 2739
will 2 w 2743
This 1 w 2748
line 3 w 2752
now 3 w 2756
found 1 w 2761
in 52 w 2763
Eur 2 w 2766
Electra 1 w 2774
379 1 w 2778
may 1 w 2782
have 2 w 2786
come 2 w 2790
into 2 w 2794
our 2 w 2797
text 1 w 2801
from 4 w 2805
the 41 w 2808
lost 1 w 2812
play 3 w 2816
Auge 2 w 2820
cf 1 w 2823
Nauck 1 w 2829
T 6 w 2831
G 3 w 2833
F 3 w 2835
2 1 w 2837
p 61 w 2839
437 1 w 2843
s 188 w 2845
v 22 w 2847
ΑΥΓΗ 1 w 2852
he 82 w 2855
got 1 w 2858
up 6 w 2860
and 10 w 2863
left 1 w 2867
the 42 w 2870
theatre 1 w 2877
For 3 w 2881
he 85 w 2883
said 5 w 2887
it 22 w 2889
was 10 w 2892
absurd 2 w 2898
to 28 w 2900
make 2 w 2904
a 221 w 2905
hue 1 w 2908
and 11 w 2911
cry 1 w 2914
about 2 w 2919
a 224 w 2920
slave 3 w 2925
who 2 w 2928
could 3 w 2933
not 5 w 2936
be 16 w 2938
found 2 w 2943
and 12 w 2947
to 29 w 2949
allow 1 w 2954
virtue 3 w 2960
to 30 w 2962
perish 1 w 2968
in 54 w 2970
this 2 w 2974
way 3 w 2977
Some 1 w 2982
one 5 w 2985
asked 3 w 2990
him 13 w 2993
whether 1 w 3000
he 88 w 3002
should 3 w 3008
marry 1 w 3013
or 23 w 3015
not 6 w 3018
and 13 w 3022
received 1 w 3030
the 45 w 3033
reply 1 w 3038
Whichever 1 w 3048
you 5 w 3051
do 3 w 3053
you 6 w 3056
will 3 w 3060
repent 1 w 3066
it 23 w 3068
He 9 w 3071
used 4 w 3075
to 31 w 3077
express 1 w 3084
his 16 w 3087
astonishment 1 w 3099
that 15 w 3103
the 46 w 3106
sculptors 1 w 3115
of 20 w 3117
marble 1 w 3123
statues 1 w 3130
should 4 w 3136
take 3 w 3140
pains 1 w 3145
to 34 w 3147
make 3 w 3151
the 47 w 3154
block 1 w 3159
of 21 w 3161
marble 2 w 3167
into 3 w 3171
a 240 w 3172
perfect 1 w 3179
likeness 1 w 3187
of 22 w 3189
a 241 w 3190
man 9 w 3193
and 14 w 3197
should 5 w 3203
take 4 w 3207
no 21 w 3209
pains 2 w 3214
about 3 w 3219
themselves 1 w 3229
lest 1 w 3233
they 2 w 3237
should 6 w 3243
turn 3 w 3247
out 4 w 3250
mere 1 w 3254
blocks 1 w 3260
not 7 w 3264
men 7 w 3267
He 10 w 3270
recommended 1 w 3281
to 36 w 3283
the 50 w 3286
young 2 w 3291
the 51 w 3294
constant 1 w 3302
use 8 w 3305
of 23 w 3307
the 52 w 3310
mirror 1 w 3316
to 37 w 3319
the 53 w 3322
end 3 w 3325
that 16 w 3329
handsome 1 w 3337
men 9 w 3340
might 2 w 3345
acquire 3 w 3352
a 251 w 3353
corresponding 1 w 3366
behaviour 1 w 3375
and 16 w 3379
ugly 1 w 3383
men 10 w 3386
conceal 1 w 3393
their 3 w 3398
defects 1 w 3405
by 3 w 3407
education 1 w 3416